93% of Pastors Are Using AI. The 75% Who Are Worried Are Asking the Right Question.
TL;DR: The widespread caution among pastors about AI's theological risks is a healthy sign of spiritual discernment, proving that efficiency must never replace faithfulness in ministry.
A new report landed this week with two numbers that seem to contradict each other, but I think they actually tell one cohesive, encouraging story. The report finds that 93% of church leaders are either using or actively exploring AI tools for their ministry. That’s not an early adopter trend; that's a sea change.
But here’s the second number. The same report reveals that 75% of those leaders cite theological misalignment as their top concern with these new tools. My first reaction wasn't alarm. It was relief.
That caution isn't fear of technology. It’s wisdom. It’s the shepherd’s instinct to protect the flock. The fact that pastors are rushing to adopt efficiency tools while holding a deep-seated concern for doctrinal integrity shows they are asking exactly the right question: how can this serve the mission of the church without subverting it?
Where AI shines, and where it must not tread
The data shows us where pastors are finding the most help. The primary areas of AI experimentation are in administration and communications . This makes perfect sense. These are tasks that consume enormous amounts of time but are adjacent to the core spiritual work of the church.
Think about it:
Drafting a weekly email newsletter.
Organizing volunteer schedules for the children's ministry.
Generating social media graphics for an upcoming event.
Transcribing last week's sermon for the church website.
These are necessary jobs, but they aren't the central calling of a pastor. If an AI can give a pastor back 5 or 10 hours a week by handling these tasks, that is time that can be reinvested in prayer, sermon preparation, hospital visits, and discipling members. Used correctly, AI doesn't replace the pastor; it frees the pastor to be more of a pastor. Many churches are already using AI ministry tools in precisely these ways.
Crucially, the report also notes the boundaries leaders are drawing. The two areas they are keeping firmly human-led are sermon preparation and pastoral counseling . Again, this is exactly right. A large language model cannot exegete Scripture with the guidance of the Holy Spirit. It cannot know the specific struggles and spiritual needs of a congregation. It cannot weep with those who weep.
These roles were given by Christ to people, for people.
And he gave some, apostles; and some, prophets; and some, evangelists; and some, pastors and teachers; For the perfecting of the saints, for the work of the ministry, for the edifying of the body of Christ:
> Ephesians 4:11-12 (KJV)
The work of teaching and shepherding is a personal, spiritual calling. Technology can and should support it, but it can never substitute for the Spirit-led human heart. The goal of ministry is not just information transfer; it's genuine spiritual formation .
The real risk of theological drift
Some might argue that using AI for sermon research is no different from using a commentary or a concordance. I see the point. As a software builder, I know these tools can be powerful research assistants, capable of surfacing information and summarizing texts in seconds. There is a place for that.
But the line between assistance and authorship is critical, and it can be blurry. The 75% of pastors who are concerned about theological drift are right to be. AI models are trained on the vast expanse of the internet, which contains a confusing mix of sound doctrine, outright heresy, secular assumptions, and cultural baggage. An AI doesn't have theological convictions. It generates text based on statistical patterns.
This can lead to subtle but significant errors:
Flattening of doctrine: An AI might present a view of salvation that strips out the necessity of repentance because it averages multiple viewpoints it found online.
Secular framing: It might discuss a biblical concept of justice through a purely modern political lens, missing the scriptural foundation.
Lack of context: It can quote a verse without understanding the surrounding passage or the author's original intent, leading to misapplication.
This is why Christian leaders must guide AI's future with diligence, not just adopt it without question. Every tool we use in ministry must be scrutinized. Does it help us do all things for the glory of God? That's the only test that matters.
A checklist for faithful AI adoption
So how do we move forward? We embrace the efficiency gains while holding fast to our theological responsibilities. For any pastor or church leader considering a new AI tool, here is a simple checklist based on what we're learning.
Area of Ministry · Key Question · Green Light (Safe to Automate) · Yellow Light (Use with Caution) · Red Light (Keep Human-Led)
Administration · Does this save time on logistics? · Volunteer scheduling, event planning, email drafts · Budget analysis · Setting church vision & policy
Communications · Does this help us communicate clearly? · Social media graphics, video captions, transcription · First drafts of blog posts, website copy · Official doctrinal statements, church discipline communication
Worship & Arts · Does this support worship of God? · Generating background slides, organizing song lists · Brainstorming song ideas · Leading worship, writing liturgy & prayers
Study & Teaching · Does this tool aid understanding of Scripture? · Checking cross-references, summarizing historical context · Sermon research, outlining key points · Writing and preaching the sermon, authorship of teaching material
Pastoral Care · Does this tool connect people to care? · Prayer list management, follow-up reminders · Generating resources for common issues · Counseling, discipleship, hospital visits, prayer
This isn't about creating a new legalism around technology. It's about applying timeless principles of wisdom and stewardship to new tools, just as the church has always done. It's about a commitment to a simple test for all church tech .
While the sermon itself must come from a pastor's deep well of study and prayer, technology can help capture and share it faithfully. For example, a tool like FaithGPT's Live Notes can transcribe a message as it's delivered, automatically identifying Scripture references and pulling out key phrases for the church website or small group notes. This supports the human preacher without replacing him.
The future is not a choice between a fully-automated church and a tech-free one. The future is a church where wise shepherds use powerful tools to free up their time and energy for the irreplaceable work of loving and leading God's people.
The 93% adoption number shows pastors are willing to engage. The 75% concern number shows they are doing so with their eyes wide open. And that is very good news.
Helpful Scripture resources
Contact & support
Email the FaithGPT team at hello@faithgpt.io or visit the contact page .
Explore FaithGPT