Why the Vatican's AI Encyclical Is a Good Start, But Not the Gospel
TL;DR: The Vatican’s recent encyclical on artificial intelligence offers a welcome Christian voice on technology, but its reliance on natural law and human reason misses the Bible's core diagnosis of sin and its ultimate solution in the Gospel.
The Vatican's new encyclical on artificial intelligence is a conversation starter every Christian should welcome, but its foundation misses the most important part of the story.
News broke last week that the Vatican presented its first-ever encyclical on AI at a summit in Geneva, according to a report from Aleteia. As a software developer building FaithGPT and a Christian trying to steward technology faithfully, my first reaction was gratitude. In a world where Big Tech often sets the ethical agenda, it’s powerful to see a major branch of the global church engage so thoughtfully.
There is so much here for Protestants, Catholics, and Orthodox Christians to agree on. The document reportedly champions human dignity, insisting that AI must serve humanity, not the other way around. It calls for what it terms "algorethics"—a push for fairness, accountability, and transparency in algorithms. These are just and right. They echo the biblical call to love our neighbor and seek justice for the vulnerable, principles that are core to any Christian ethics framework for AI.
When the church speaks with a unified voice on the inherent worth of every person, created in God’s image, the world should listen. This is a profound point of common ground.
Where we agree (and why it matters)
I lead a small group at my church, and we often discuss how to apply our faith to our work and family life. The Vatican’s push for human-centric AI is a perfect example of applying a biblical principle to a modern problem. We can and should applaud their efforts to:
- *Uphold the Imago Dei***: The encyclical’s core argument that technology must respect the dignity of the human person is deeply biblical. We are not just complex machines or data points; we are image-bearers of the living God.
- Promote Justice: Calling for transparency and fighting bias in AI systems is a direct application of passages like Micah 6:8, which calls us to “do justly.” An algorithm that unfairly denies someone a loan or a job interview is an instrument of injustice.
- Encourage Wise Stewardship: By issuing this guidance, the Vatican is exercising a form of technological stewardship, calling creators and users to build and deploy these tools with wisdom and foresight.
Now, the strongest counter-argument to my critique is simple: “This is a Catholic document for Catholics. Why are you, a Protestant, even picking it apart? Isn’t it good that any Christian voice is entering the global AI conversation?”
That’s a fair question. And the answer is yes, it is overwhelmingly good. I would much rather have the Vatican speaking into this space than have a silent church. Their voice adds moral weight and helps frame the debate around human dignity, which benefits everyone. But as believers who hold the Bible as our final authority, we must be discerning readers. We can affirm the good while also gently pointing to what is better, and what is ultimate.
The real problem isn't bad ethics; it's the human heart
Here is where a Protestant, Gospel-centered perspective diverges. The encyclical, like much Catholic social teaching, builds its case on Scripture, Tradition, and natural law. It trusts that human reason, rightly applied, can guide us toward ethical solutions.
But the Bible gives us a more sobering diagnosis of the human condition.
The heart is deceitful above all things, and desperately wicked: who can know it?
Jeremiah 17:9 (KJV)
The root problem with technology is not the technology itself; it's the sinful human heart that wields it. AI doesn't have a moral compass, but it is an incredibly powerful amplifier of the moral (or immoral) compass of its creators and users. A biased algorithm is not the result of a bug in the code as much as it is a feature of the fallen hearts that trained it on biased data.
Better ethics, improved regulations, and human-in-the-loop systems are all good, necessary, and worthy pursuits. But they are downstream solutions. They are behavioral modifications that do not address the root disease.
The ultimate Christian solution is not a better ethical framework but a redeemed and transformed heart through the Gospel of Jesus Christ. It is only the regenerating work of the Holy Spirit that can truly reorient our desires toward loving God and our neighbor, whether we are coding an algorithm or having a conversation.
This distinction changes everything. It’s the difference between seeing AI ethics as a checklist and seeing it as an overflow of a life submitted to Christ.
Here’s a quick breakdown of the different starting points:
Principle · Vatican's Likely Approach · A Gospel-Centered Approach
Source of Authority · Scripture, Tradition, Natural Law · Scripture Alone (Sola Scriptura)
Diagnosis of Problem · Flawed ethics, lack of humanism · Sin, the fallen human heart
Proposed Solution · Better regulation, "algorethics" · Gospel transformation, Spirit-led wisdom
Ultimate Hope · Human-centric technology · Redemption and new creation in Christ
This isn't just theological hair-splitting. It has real-world consequences. As a dad, I'm not just teaching my kids a set of rules for using technology. I'm trying to shepherd their hearts, praying that they would love what God loves and hate what God hates. My wife and I know that their ultimate protection online comes from a heart that wants to honor Jesus, not just a list of do's and don'ts. This is why having a solid guide for talking to your kids about faith and AI is so important.
As we navigate these complex issues, our first instinct must be to turn to God's Word. What does Scripture have to say about truth, wisdom, creation, and work? How do we apply timeless principles to this new frontier? For many of us, starting to build these biblical convictions can feel daunting. Exploring topics like these with a tool like FaithGPT can be a helpful first step, pointing you to relevant Scriptures and helping you organize your thoughts for prayer and further study.
So I’m genuinely thankful for the Vatican’s work. Let’s read the encyclical. Let’s partner with our Catholic friends to advocate for justice and human dignity in the public square. Let's work together where we can.
But let’s never mistake a good ethical framework for the power of the Gospel.
Let’s build better AI, but let’s never forget that only God can build a better human.
Helpful Scripture resources
Contact & support
Email the FaithGPT team at hello@faithgpt.io or visit the contact page.
Explore FaithGPT
